Woman looking through a trunk filled with secondhand clothing, shoes, and handbags while sorting items to sell for cash at consignment and resale stores.

15 Stores That Pay Cash For Your Used Stuff

disclosure

Have a closet full of clothes you never wear, kids’ toys collecting dust, or sporting equipment taking up space in the garage? Before you donate everything or spend hours listing items on Facebook Marketplace, you might be surprised to learn that some stores will actually pay you cash for your used stuff.

From clothing and baby gear to electronics, books, and furniture, there are plenty of resale stores that buy secondhand merchandise. Some pay cash on the spot, while others offer store credit or pay you after your items sell.

The best part? You don’t have to photograph every item, write descriptions, negotiate with strangers, or worry about shipping packages.

Here are 15 stores that pay cash for your used stuff, along with what they buy and tips for getting the most money.

1. Plato’s Closet

If you have trendy clothing, shoes, or accessories you no longer wear, Plato’s Closet is one of the most recognizable resale chains.

Plato’s Closet specializes in gently used, current-style clothing and accessories for teens and young adults. Popular brands, athletic wear, sneakers, denim, and seasonal fashion tend to be good candidates.

What they buy: Clothing, shoes, handbags, hats, and accessories.

How you get paid: Cash on the spot for items the store accepts.

Tip: Bring freshly laundered clothing in excellent condition. Trendy brands and current styles generally have a better chance of being accepted than outdated clothing.

2. Once Upon a Child

Kids outgrow everything so quickly that their closets can become a miniature inventory warehouse. Once Upon a Child helps parents turn those outgrown items into money.

The chain buys gently used children’s clothing, shoes, toys, books, and certain baby equipment. Stores generally look for clean, safe merchandise in good working condition.

What they buy: Children’s clothing, shoes, toys, baby gear, books, and accessories.

How you get paid: Cash on the spot for accepted items.

Tip: Bring complete toy sets with all their pieces. Check that baby equipment hasn’t been recalled, and contact your local store about which categories it currently accepts.

3. Play It Again Sports

Have golf clubs sitting in the garage or sports equipment your kids have outgrown? Play It Again Sports specializes in buying and selling used sporting goods.

Depending on the location, you may be able to sell everything from baseball gloves and hockey equipment to golf clubs, exercise equipment, and bicycles.

What they buy: Sports equipment, fitness gear, bicycles, golf clubs, and more.

How you get paid: Cash or store credit, depending on the store and transaction.

Tip: Clean your equipment and bring any accessories or attachments. Seasonal demand can make a difference, so selling baseball equipment before baseball season may be smarter than waiting until winter.

4. Style Encore

If your closet is filled with women’s fashion that no longer fits your style, Style Encore may be worth visiting.

Unlike Plato’s Closet, which focuses more on younger shoppers, Style Encore buys gently used women’s clothing, shoes, handbags, and accessories across a broader range of adult styles.

What they buy: Women’s clothing, handbags, shoes, jewelry, and accessories.

How you get paid: Cash on the spot for accepted merchandise.

Tip: Designer handbags, quality denim, and popular name brands may be particularly appealing. Make sure everything is clean, fashionable, and in excellent condition.

5. Clothes Mentor

Clothes Mentor is another resale chain that specializes in women’s clothing and accessories.

The store generally focuses on contemporary women’s fashion, including everyday clothing, professional attire, shoes, and handbags.

What they buy: Women’s clothing, designer handbags, shoes, jewelry, and accessories.

How you get paid: Cash on the spot for accepted items.

Tip: If you have higher-end clothing or handbags, consider comparing offers from Clothes Mentor and Style Encore before deciding where to sell.

6. Uptown Cheapskate

Uptown Cheapskate buys and sells trendy secondhand fashion, making it another option for cleaning out your closet.

The chain focuses on stylish clothing, shoes, and accessories, including popular brands and streetwear.

What they buy: Men’s and women’s clothing, shoes, handbags, and accessories.

How you get paid: Cash or store credit for accepted items.

Tip: Bring current styles and desirable brands. Some locations offer more in store credit than cash, so compare the options before accepting an offer.

7. Buffalo Exchange

Buffalo Exchange is a well-known resale chain that buys fashionable secondhand clothing.

Its selection often includes vintage fashion, unique pieces, designer clothing, and current trends. If your closet includes statement pieces or interesting vintage finds, this could be a good place to start.

What they buy: Clothing, shoes, and fashion accessories.

How you get paid: Cash or trade credit for accepted items.

Tip: Vintage doesn’t necessarily mean valuable. Focus on pieces that are fashionable, well-preserved, and likely to appeal to the store’s shoppers.

8. Half Price Books

If your bookshelves are overflowing, Half Price Books could help turn your old books into extra spending money.

The chain buys used books and other entertainment merchandise. Certain locations may also purchase records, movies, games, and collectible items.

What they buy: Books, DVDs, CDs, vinyl records, video games, and select collectibles.

How you get paid: Cash for accepted items.

Tip: Bring books in good condition, especially newer releases, popular titles, and collectible editions. Don’t expect every paperback to be worth much, but selling a large collection can be a convenient way to declutter.

9. 2nd & Charles

2nd & Charles is another resale retailer that buys used entertainment merchandise.

Depending on the location, you may be able to sell used electronics, books, video games, movies, music, and collectibles.

What they buy: Books, games, movies, music, and select collectibles or electronics.

How you get paid: Cash or store credit for qualifying items.

Tip: Compare the cash offer with the store-credit offer. If you’re already planning to buy books or games, store credit may give you more value.

10. GameStop

Have an old gaming console or a stack of video games you no longer play? GameStop offers trade-ins on eligible gaming merchandise.

GameStop is especially convenient if you’re upgrading to a newer console or want to get rid of older games.

What they buy: Eligible video games, gaming consoles, controllers, and certain electronics.

How you get paid: Cash or trade credit, subject to current eligibility and store policies.

Tip: Check trade-in values online before visiting. Make sure consoles work properly, remove your personal information, and bring the required cords and controllers.

11. Music Go Round

If you have musical instruments collecting dust, Music Go Round specializes in used musical gear.

Whether you stopped playing guitar or have equipment from an old band, selling it to a music resale store may be easier than finding an individual buyer.

What they buy: Guitars, keyboards, drums, amplifiers, microphones, and other musical equipment.

How you get paid: Cash or store credit for accepted items.

Tip: Test your equipment before visiting. Instruments in working condition with their original cases and accessories may be more attractive to buyers.

12. Cash America Pawn

Cash America Pawn is a pawn shop chain that purchases various secondhand items, depending on the location.

Unlike specialty resale stores, pawn shops may buy merchandise across several categories, including jewelry, electronics, tools, and musical instruments.

What they buy: Jewelry, electronics, tools, musical instruments, and other items of value.

How you get paid: Cash for items the store agrees to purchase.

Tip: Be sure you understand the difference between selling and pawning. Selling transfers ownership permanently, while pawning typically involves using your item as collateral for a loan that must be repaid to reclaim it.

13. The LEGO Store (Brick Trade-In Programs)

If you have a large collection of LEGO bricks, you may have options for turning them into money, although this one works differently from traditional resale stores.

LEGO has operated limited brick trade-in and recycling initiatives, but regular LEGO Stores do not generally offer cash for used LEGO sets or loose bricks.

Instead, look for independent LEGO resale shops, such as participating Bricks & Minifigs locations, which may buy used LEGO collections.

What they buy: At participating independent resale stores, LEGO bricks, sets, minifigures, and collections.

How you get paid: Cash or store credit, depending on the independent store.

Tip: Complete sets, original instructions, and sought-after minifigures may be worth more than mixed bulk bricks. Check your collection before selling everything by weight.

14. Kid to Kid

Kid to Kid is another children’s resale franchise that buys gently used items from families.

Like Once Upon a Child, Kid to Kid focuses on children’s merchandise and can be a convenient way to clear out items your kids have outgrown.

What they buy: Children’s clothing, shoes, toys, books, and select baby equipment.

How you get paid: Cash or store credit for accepted items.

Tip: Bring seasonal clothing, clean shoes, and toys with all their pieces. If you have both Kid to Kid and Once Upon a Child nearby, consider comparing their offers.

15. Local Furniture Consignment and Resale Stores

Furniture can be one of the most valuable categories to resell, especially if you have quality pieces in excellent condition.

Local furniture consignment stores may accept sofas, dining tables, bedroom furniture, home decor, and other household items.

However, traditional consignment works differently from stores that buy items outright. With consignment, the store displays your furniture and pays you a portion of the selling price after it sells.

What they buy or accept: Furniture, home decor, lamps, artwork, and other household items.

How you get paid: Some resale stores buy furniture outright, while consignment shops pay after your item sells.

Tip: Contact the store before transporting large furniture. Many shops want photos first, and some only accept particular styles, brands, or furniture in nearly new condition.

Quick Comparison: Which Stores Pay Cash for Used Stuff?

Store Best Items to Sell Payment
Plato’s Closet Trendy clothing Cash
Once Upon a Child Kids’ clothing and gear Cash
Play It Again Sports Sports equipment Cash or credit
Style Encore Women’s fashion Cash
Clothes Mentor Women’s clothing and handbags Cash
Uptown Cheapskate Trendy fashion Cash or credit
Buffalo Exchange Vintage and trendy clothing Cash or trade
Half Price Books Books and media Cash
2nd & Charles Books, games, collectibles Cash or credit
GameStop Video games and consoles Cash or credit
Music Go Round Musical instruments Cash or credit
Cash America Pawn Jewelry, tools, electronics Cash
Independent LEGO resale shops LEGO sets and bricks Cash or credit
Kid to Kid Kids’ clothing and toys Cash or credit
Furniture resale shops Furniture and decor Cash or consignment

Buying policies, payment methods, and accepted merchandise vary by location. Call ahead before making a special trip.

How to Get the Most Money for Your Used Stuff

Before loading up your car and heading to a resale store, a little preparation can help you get a better offer.

  1. Clean everything first. Wash clothing, wipe down shoes, and remove dust from electronics and toys. Presentation matters.

  2. Research your items. Check sold listings on eBay to see what similar items have actually sold for.

  3. Know which brands stores want. A resale store may pay more for popular brands than for generic merchandise.

  4. Bring complete sets. Toys, electronics, and sporting equipment are generally easier to sell when all the pieces and accessories are included.

  5. Compare offers. If you have several resale stores nearby, consider visiting more than one.

  6. Bring identification. Many stores require a valid government-issued photo ID before purchasing merchandise.

  7. Don’t take rejection personally. Stores make buying decisions based on inventory, demand, condition, and current trends. An item rejected at one store might sell at another.

Cash vs. Store Credit vs. Consignment: What’s the Difference?

Not every secondhand store pays the same way.

Cash on the spot: The store examines your merchandise, makes an offer, and pays you immediately if you accept. Plato’s Closet and Once Upon a Child are examples.

Store credit: Some retailers offer a higher amount if you accept credit toward future purchases instead of cash. This can be worthwhile if you regularly shop there.

Consignment: The store sells your merchandise on your behalf and pays you an agreed-upon percentage after it sells. This can potentially earn you more money, but payment isn’t guaranteed.

For people who want quick money without waiting for a buyer, stores that purchase merchandise outright are usually the most convenient option.

Is Selling to Resale Stores Worth It?

It depends on what you’re selling and how much time you’re willing to invest.

Resale stores need to make a profit, so they typically offer considerably less than the amount they expect to sell your merchandise for.

For example, if a store plans to resell a pair of jeans for $20, it might offer you only $4 to $8. That’s an illustration, not a guaranteed payout.

You might make more by selling the jeans yourself through eBay, Poshmark, Mercari, or Facebook Marketplace. However, that also means taking photos, creating listings, answering questions, and possibly shipping the merchandise.

The biggest advantage of selling to resale stores is convenience. You can walk in with unwanted merchandise and potentially leave with cash the same day.

Frequently Asked Questions

What stores pay cash for used clothes?

Plato’s Closet, Style Encore, Clothes Mentor, Uptown Cheapskate, Buffalo Exchange, and Kid to Kid are among the chains that buy eligible used clothing. Each has different brand, style, and condition requirements.

Do consignment stores pay you immediately?

Traditional consignment stores usually pay after your merchandise sells. Buy-sell-trade stores such as Plato’s Closet purchase accepted items outright and pay immediately.

What used items are easiest to sell for cash?

Popular clothing brands, gaming consoles, sporting equipment, musical instruments, children’s toys, and quality electronics can be good candidates. Demand and condition play a major role.

Can you negotiate with resale stores?

Some independent resale shops may negotiate, but many chains use established buying guidelines. You’re generally free to decline an offer and take your merchandise elsewhere.

What should I do with items a resale store won’t buy?

Try another resale store, list them online, host a garage sale, or donate them to a local charity. You can also bundle lower-value items together to make them more appealing to buyers.

Final Thoughts

You don’t need to start an online reselling business to make money from things you already own.

Stores like Plato’s Closet, Once Upon a Child, Play It Again Sports, and Half Price Books make it possible to turn unwanted merchandise into cash without the hassle of finding individual buyers.

Start with one closet, bookshelf, or storage bin. Sort out anything you no longer use, check which resale stores are nearby, and see what they’ll offer.

You might not get rich selling your old stuff, but turning clutter into extra cash is a win for both your wallet and your home.

And before you donate that bag of name-brand clothes or box of forgotten toys, remember: someone else might be willing to pay for what you no longer need.

Pinterest graphic featuring the words "15 Stores That Pay Cash for Your Used Stuff" with folded clothing, books, a basketball, a toy truck, and cash, highlighting ways to make money selling unwanted items.